Course: Introduction / Criminal Law
The infancy defense is a common law doctrine that very young children were incapable of forming a culpable mental state and, thus, were not subject to criminal prosecution.
The infancy defense is a legal doctrine that has its origins in the common law. The doctrine holds that young children, usually under the age of seven or eight, are not capable of forming the mental state necessary to commit a crime and, therefore, cannot be held criminally responsible for their actions.
The underlying rationale for the infancy defense is that young children lack the cognitive development and maturity necessary to understand the consequences of their actions or to appreciate the wrongfulness of their conduct. As such, they cannot be held to the same standard of culpability as adults.
However, the infancy defense is not absolute. While young children may not be subject to criminal prosecution, they can still be subject to other forms of legal intervention, such as placement in juvenile detention or rehabilitation programs. Additionally, the defense may not apply in cases where the child in question has a demonstrated history of violence or criminal behavior or where the child’s actions were particularly heinous or violent.
The infancy defense has been the subject of much debate in recent years, with some arguing that it is an outdated and arbitrary standard that fails to account for the complexity of childhood development. Critics of the defense argue that it can create perverse incentives for parents or guardians to encourage or even facilitate criminal behavior by young children, knowing that they will not be held accountable for their actions.
On the other hand, supporters of the defense argue that it serves a valuable purpose in protecting young children from the harsh consequences of criminal prosecution and in recognizing the unique vulnerabilities and limitations of childhood.
Ultimately, the application of the infancy defense remains a matter of legal interpretation and judgment. While it is clear that young children are generally not held criminally responsible for their actions, the precise standards and criteria for determining when the defense applies can vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction and case to case.
On This Site
- Criminal Justice | Section 1.2: Roles, Objectives, and Limits in Criminal Justice
- Criminal Law » Section 2.5 »
[ Glossary ]
Last Modified: 04/05/2023